I have used tons of eyeliners and one of them was this maybelline new york hyper sharp liner. I am not a great for eyeliners, I personally dont use them everyday ( I cant waste my 5-10 mins lining my eyes) . But still I have used many eyeliners for most of functions and have tried many. This eyeliner is good but not the best I assure you that. Their are great gel liners too. This has a felt tip to give you that extra precision which is the most I am fond of. Applying liner slecially gel liners haunts me, so mostly I use felt tip liners. This is a good liner but its pigmentation is not quite good its not quite dark. But still it gives you the pricision which is good thing. It costs for 375/-. It claims to be waterproof but it is not, but you dont expect a liner to stay put in after a shower too, but it remains for 5-6 hours forsure.
Pros:
-good precision
-good for the price
-handy
-even an amateur can apply it perfectly
Cons:
-not quite pigmented
-not waterproof